The McGraw-Hill Companies
STANDARD & POOR'S

Ratings

 


CDO Spotlight: S&P Updates Criteria For Valuing Assets In Market Value Transactions
Primary Credit Analysts:
Jean-Baptiste Carelus, New York (1) 212-438-3910;
jean-baptiste_carelus@standardandpoors.com
Francesca L Neilson, New York (1) 212-438-5056;
francesca_neilson@standardandpoors.com
James Halprin, New York (1) 212-438-5048;
james_halprin@standardandpoors.com
Secondary Credit Analyst:
David Tesher, New York (1) 212-438-2618;
david_tesher@standardandpoors.com
Publication date: 11-Jan-07, 15:24:25 EST
Reprinted from RatingsDirect


Standard & Poor's Ratings Services has updated its criteria for asset valuation in a market value transaction. In a market value transaction, Standard & Poor's focuses on the amount and quality of the assets held in a portfolio and assigns a rating to those assets. The rating addresses the likelihood that a pool of assets will, at all times, maintain a value that is sufficient to cover the payment of all liabilities. Inadequate or incorrect pricing of the collateral may lead to an insufficient amount of assets available to pay the issuer's obligation when due.

Asset sufficiency is assured through a minimum asset coverage (MAC) test or an overcollateralization test (the MAC's inverse). The issuer/administrator performs the MAC test periodically to monitor whether the assets' value is being maintained. In market value transactions, the market value, or the price of an issue's assets, fluctuates daily and the assets are marked to market regularly on the valuation date. To determine the discounted value of these assets for the MAC test, the market value of each asset is multiplied by Standard & Poor's advance rates (or Standard & Poor's discount factors). The advance rates ensure that the fund or issuer will have sufficient assets to cover any payment obligation in the event of collateral liquidation, despite potential price volatility in the market for the underlying portfolio of assets.

Advance rates differ depending on several variables, including the price volatility of the asset, the exposure period, and the desired rating, and reflect the market volatility of the assets over a specific time period. For any non-U.S. dollar-denominated asset, an additional currency discount must be applied unless at least 95% of the asset is hedged against currency fluctuation. Advance rates are not applied to cash held in U.S. dollars.


Standard & Poor's Methodology


Proceeds/capital contribution

The proceeds from a market value transaction are used to acquire a number of different asset types that are held by the issuer, including:

  • U.S. government securities,
  • MBS,
  • Corporate bonds,
  • Bank loans,
  • Equity securities,
  • Structured finance securities,
  • Short-term money market instruments,
  • Loans to affiliates supported by LOCs,
  • Municipal bonds, and
  • Foreign securities.

Eligible assets

In a market value transaction, Standard & Poor's accepts as eligible assets those securities for which a well-developed secondary market exists. If Standard & Poor's does not have a rating outstanding on an eligible asset, the asset is notched one full category below the equivalent Standard & Poor's rating for investment-grade assets. Speculative-grade assets not rated by Standard & Poor's can be notched two full categories below the equivalent Standard & Poor's rating or carried as a not-rated asset (NR). Notching is allowed only on public ratings.

In addition, assets must be maintained to cover the liquidation preference and dividends for preferred stock, principal and interest for debt issues, and various other expenses. The level at which these assets must be maintained depends on several factors, including:

  • The type of security,
  • The frequency of the securities' valuation,
  • The time allowed to cure a deficiency of the required asset level from the date of a failed valuation,
  • The time needed to liquidate the collateral and redeem the rated obligations if a failed valuation remains uncured, and
  • The desired rating on the issue.

In addition to the quality and value of the assets held in a portfolio, Standard & Poor's requires other parameters essential for maintaining a diversified portfolio, which are listed as portfolio limits in the transaction's legal documents.


Calculating The MAC Test

In a market value transaction, the issuance proceeds are used to obtain assets. The income from those assets held and the income from the sale of those assets, if necessary, act as the credit support for the issue's obligations. Standard & Poor's criteria require that a minimum level of assets be maintained in the issuer's portfolio to protect security holders (the required or minimum asset coverage). The valuation date is the date on which the computation is made by following the steps listed below.


Calculating the discounted value of eligible assets

Ineligible assets, securities for which advance rates are not established or that exceed the concentration limits beyond 10% of total portfolio value (such as by issuer, industry, or sector), in addition to other factors that prevent it from being considered an eligible asset, are eliminated from the pool of assets to determine the MAC. Portfolio holdings that exceed the transaction's percentage limits can be included as eligible assets. The advance rate will be reduced by two percentage points for each percentage point in excess of the limit. Portfolio holdings in excess of 10% of the total portfolio value are considered ineligible assets. In earlier market value transactions, Standard & Poor's allowed only settlement date accounting (once a trade settles, the manager discounts the assets as cash). Receivables from a trade due within five business days are treated the same as cash; the advance rate is 100%. If the receivables from the trade are not due within five days, those receivables are discounted at the assets' given advance rate.


Determining market value

Standard & Poor's determines the market value of eligible assets according to the following order of priority:

  • A pricing service. The pricing service must have been reviewed by Standard & Poor's before the issuer can add it to a list of approved pricing services;
  • Dealer bids. If a pricing service is not used, or the pricing service is not able to provide a price, the market value of an asset can be determined by the average of three dealer bid prices. If three bid prices are not available, market value is determined using the lower of two dealer bid prices. The bid prices must be from dealers making a market in such security. For U.S. securities, the dealers must be members of the National Association of Securities Dealers Inc. For non-U.S. securities, the dealers must be members of a dealer panel. At least one of the bids must be in writing. Standard & Poor's accepts as dealers companies that are registered, fully regulated, and whose main line of business is the trading of securities on an open market; or
  • Closing market prices from a stock exchange.

Up to 5% of the portfolio's market value may be determined by a method other than those outlined above, including self-marking or marks from the originator of the asset if other independent sources are not available. The discounted value of each asset and then the sum of the discounted assets are calculated.


Calculating the liabilities

The issuer's liabilities are deducted from the total of the discounted assets. Those liabilities include current and projected operating expenses, possible tax liabilities, payables, and any other indebtedness that the issuer may incur over the exposure period. Expenses are typically projected out to the marked-to-market frequency of illiquid assets, which usually consist of private equity. As private equity is typically marked–to-market quarterly, Standard & Poor's requires expenses to be projected to at least 90 days.

Dividends or interest are also deducted from the total discounted assets. Coverage for dividends or interest must be equal to the current amount due, which is the amount that will accrue from the valuation date to the end of the current dividend or interest period. The current amount is the product of the number of days remaining in the current period; the current dividend or interest rate; and the face value of the preferred stock, notes, or bonds. Assets are marked-to-market to account for price movements, but it is also necessary to account for the potential increases in dividend or interest rates during the exposure period because an auction or remarketing of the preferred shares could occur or the interest period could reset.

The total amount of liabilities is subtracted from the total discounted value of Standard & Poor's eligible assets (see Calculating The MAC for an example of this calculation for a market value preferred stock transaction). The MAC test is met if, after deducting liabilities and dividend or interest coverage, the remaining discounted assets are at least equal to the total liabilities outstanding.

If any coverage is not met on any valuation date, the issuer has a short period of time to cure this asset deficiency by changing the asset mix in the portfolio until the MAC test is met. If the MAC test is still not met on the cure date, depending on the type of transaction and the terms of the structure, a partial redemption is triggered until coverage levels are returned or a mandatory redemption will occur.


Liquidity Coverage For Dividends And Interest

Standard & Poor's criteria require that the issuer maintain a percentage of assets in liquid form to ensure the timely payment of dividends and interest. Liquid assets typically consist of short-term money market instruments (such as certificates of deposit or CP), U.S. Treasuries, short-term municipal securities, and cash. Debt issues may use a liquidity facility to meet interest payment dates. A U.S. or non-U.S. special-purpose subsidiary may include credit-enhanced payments that are received or will be received before the next dividend payment date. Funds may include short-term securities that are rated 'A-1+' by Standard & Poor's, which mature, or have demand features exercisable, at most three days before the next dividend or interest payment date. On each valuation date, there must be sufficient liquid assets to cover all dividend and interest payments due on or before the next dividend payment date.


Mandatory Redemption/Trigger Events

The issuer, in most instances, must redeem the securities if the discounted value of the assets held is not sufficient to meet its MAC test and such deficiency is not cured by a specified cure date. If the issuer is a leveraged closed-end fund (a registered investment or business development company), preferred shares must also be redeemed if the fund fails to meet certain requirements under the Investment Company Act of 1940. Due to the high level of asset coverage, it is necessary, in most cases, to liquidate some of the assets. In a market value transaction, the issuer has the flexibility to effect a partial redemption of the shares to maintain asset coverage.


Analytic services provided by Standard & Poor's Ratings Services (Ratings Services) are the result of separate activities designed to preserve the independence and objectivity of ratings opinions. The credit ratings and observations contained herein are solely statements of opinion and not statements of fact or recommendations to purchase, hold, or sell any securities or make any other investment decisions. Accordingly, any user of the information contained herein should not rely on any credit rating or other opinion contained herein in making any investment decision. Ratings are based on information received by Ratings Services. Other divisions of Standard & Poor's may have information that is not available to Ratings Services. Standard & Poor's has established policies and procedures to maintain the confidentiality of non-public information received during the ratings process.

Ratings Services receives compensation for its ratings. Such compensation is normally paid either by the issuers of such securities or third parties participating in marketing the securities. While Standard & Poor's reserves the right to disseminate the rating, it receives no payment for doing so, except for subscriptions to its publications. Additional information about our ratings fees is available at www.standardandpoors.com/usratingsfees.